Most employment
decisions are based on interviewing the applicant. But most interviews don't provide us
with sufficient information to make an informed decision. As a consequence, most hiring
decisions are based on who the interviewers like best. This is akin to deciding to get
married on the first date. To conduct more effective interviews, follow these principles:
- Ask questions which allow the candidate to do at least 70%
of the talking. For the most part, avoid questions that can be answered "yes" or
"no." The best questions are ones in which the candidates recount their past
experience.
- Phrase your questions so that the desired or
"right" answer is not apparent to the applicant.
- Ask only one question about one subject at a time.
- Ask the easy questions first so as to make the applicant
feel comfortable.
- All questions should be directly related to finding out
about the applicant's ability to do the job, not about his or her personal life.
- Spend the entire time writing, recording the candidate's
answers and any assumptions you are making.
- Interviews are generally a poor place to test the
candidate's skills, other than the skill of being interviewed. Some interpersonal skills
can be tested, however, through the use of role-playing with the applicant.
- While you are writing, nod occasionally to let the applicant
know you are listening.
- If the applicant doesn't respond right away to a question,
wait. Give them time, while you add to your notes.
- Follow up: ask the person to tell you more, to give more
details.
- Ask the candidate to describe their past behavior in the
kind of situations they will encounter on the job.
- Alternate between easy, non-threatening questions and more
difficult, pointed ones.
- After you have asked the candidate all your questions, allow
them time to ask you any questions they have about the job.
- Close the interview by asking the candidate if there is
anything they regret saying, any answer they'd like to change, or anything they'd like to
add to their previous statements.
- Spend at least thirty minutes reviewing your notes after the
interview and identifying any key qualities that you feel you have not adequately tested.
These become objectives for subsequent interviews or for assessment experiences.
Types of interviewing Questions
Skilled interviewers use a variety of types of questions to draw the most information from
the candidate. These are listed below in the approximate order in which they might be
asked.
Permission Questions
Permission questions demonstrate concern for the other party. They are used at the
beginning of the interview to put the other person at ease. Examples include:
- Are there any questions you have about the process before we
begin the interview?
- Is there anything I can do to make you more comfortable
before we begin? . Okay if we start with question one?
Factual Questions:
Factual questions are low-risk attempts to obtain objective data about the applicant. They
are intended to give you a picture of the status of the other party. These questions can
be used to help make the applicant feel comfortable and are good to use at the beginning
of the interview and after a particularly difficult or threatening question. Examples
include:
- What do you do in your present job?
- How long have you worked there?
- What attracted you to our company?
Tell Me About Questions:
These questions are the most important in a hiring interview. They ask the candidate to
describe their past experience. Examples include:
- Tell me about a recent important decision you made and how
you went about it.
- Walk me through the first and last half hour of your most
recent normal workday.
What did you do first, second, etc.?
- Tell me about a recent work assignment that made you look
forward to going to work.
Feeling Questions:
Feeling questions are designed to obtain subjective data on the other party's feelings,
values and beliefs. They are useful as follow-ups to Tell Me About or Factual Questions.
Make sure that the applicant responds by describing an emotional state, not by describing
what they thought. Examples include:
- How did you feel about that reaction?
- What do you like best (least) about your present job?
- How would you feel if this were to occur?
Magic Wand Questions:
Magic Wand Questions encourage the other party to speculate or dream. They are give you an
idea of the creativity and aspirations of the candidate. Examples include:
- If you could change anything in your present work
environment, what would it be?
- What would a perfect relationship with your boss be like?
- If you were put in charge of a volunteer program, what would
you do first?
Tell Me More Questions:
These questions are used as follow-up to any of the other kinds of questions. Examples
include:
- Can you be more specific?
- What other approaches did you consider before you tried
that?
- Then what happened?
Checking Questions:
Checking questions allow you to make sure you
understand the other person's answer. They are useful at any point in the interview but
most useful at the end to help you check any assumptions you have made about the
applicant. Examples include:
- Is this what you mean?
- As I understand it, your plan of action is this. Am I right?
- Are you saying that was a negative experience?
Sample Competency Model
Below is a sample competency model for hiring an
administrative assistant in a small business. This model is intended only to provide
samples of the kinds of competencies listed in a competency model and is not intended for
use in actually hiring such a person.
| Knowledge: |
Basic understanding of the business we are in.
Knowledge of how to use Microsoft Word.
Knowledge of how to use Microsoft Excel.
Basic accounting knowledge.
|
| Skills: |
Keyboard skills.
Basic book-keeping skills.
Positive presentation of self.
Ability to organize information systems
Good time management skills
Skill in using quantitative reports
|
| Attitudes: |
Proactive (takes initiative)
Reliable
Positive attitude
Enthusiasm
Positive work ethic
Burning desire to make the boss look good.
|
| Credentials: |
Technical school degree in business
administration
|
| Experiences: |
Preparing budgets
Using appropriate software
Preparing business documents
Setting up a filing system
Interacting with the public
Purchasing supplies
|
| Affiliations: |
Member of appropriate professional
organizations.
Knowing people in our field
|
Copyright, Lynch Associates, 1996
|